Unmatched tyres (by a digit) would have failed an MOT except that they swapped rogue for the spare. Had there been a serious accident, waranting close inspection, I could have been in serious trouble. Having different tyres, especially on the front axle, could mean that you are not in proper control.
However, with regard to the age of the tyre, I have been advised by tyre retailers that I should throw away the unused spare 8 years old. NO! Check the gov.uk website - the only tyres with a legal life limit are those on the front axle of a PSV (bus, etc). The tyre may become illegal for other reasons, e.g. sidewall cracks, but age is NOT an automatic limitation. Much depends on where you keep it. Ours is in the benign storage of the camper's garage; exposed to the elements, especially the sun, won't help.