I did this comparison over the past 3 weeks away to N Scotland and back, I only ever buy supermarket diesel fuel and did so throughout the early holiday and averaged 32.8,lots of M ways, A roads and some even single track. Around mid 2nd week I changed to garage fuel exclusively, not the expensive super stuff just the normal fuel, mostly Esso but of course usually 3p or more expensive than Asda, this stuff returned 35.1 for the 2nd half of the trip, not scientific I know but the best I've ever returned, this with a Euro6 Relay.BTW the cheapest I saw on the whole trip was near Ullapool at 1.24.9 a litre which I though was bizarre.